Both plastics go onto a CNC mill and come off clear. They look similar on the shelf and behave like opposite materials on the machine and in service. Acrylic (PMMA, Plexiglas) machines crisp, polishes to optical clarity, and cracks if you look at it wrong. Polycarbonate (PC, Lexan) survives a hammer hit and melts a gummy edge that sticks to the cutter. Picking between them comes down to one question: does the part need optics, or does it need impact? This article breaks the two down on machining, mechanicals, and cost so the choice takes ten minutes, not a prototype cycle.
Optical and mechanical basics
Acrylic transmits about 92 percent of visible light, the highest of any clear plastic, and it holds a polished surface without yellowing for years indoors. Its weakness is toughness: notched Izod impact strength sits around 0.3-0.5 ft-lb/in, and a 3 mm sheet cracked by a dropped screwdriver is the classic shop-floor demo. Polycarbonate transmits about 88-90 percent of visible light, slightly hazier, and notched Izod jumps to 12-16 ft-lb/in, which is why police riot shields and bullet-resistant glazing are PC. Tensile strength is close enough not to matter: acrylic 70 MPa, PC 65 MPa. Heat resistance flips the other way, acrylic softening around 80-90 C and PC holding to 115-130 C. If the part sees a warm enclosure or a lens near a lamp, the temperature line decides before the impact line does.
How each one machines on the CNC
Acrylic cuts clean with a sharp, high-rake end mill at 3,000-6,000 RPM and a feed that keeps chips flowing. It likes climb milling and a light air blast; flood coolant can thermal-shock the sheet and craze it. Polishing takes the edge from milled to optical: flame polishing or buffing on edges that matter. Polycarbonate is the opposite temperament. It is softer and gummy, so a dull tool loads up and smears a white edge on every cut. Use sharp, polished-flute cutters, moderate RPM (2,000-4,000), and a feed that does not dwell. Coolant is safer on PC than on acrylic because PC resists thermal shock, but chip evacuation matters more. Tapping is the trap: acrylic taps clean, but PC threads strip out easily under repeated assembly, so design in threaded inserts or undersized holes. Our guide to CNC machining polycarbonate covers the feeds and fixtures that keep edges clear.
Tolerances and dimensional behavior
Both plastics expand more than aluminum, roughly 70 x 10-6 / C for acrylic and 65-70 x 10-6 / C for PC, so a 200 mm window moves 0.03-0.04 mm between a cold morning and a warm afternoon. Design slotted holes for fasteners that span that distance. Acrylic is stiffer and more brittle, so thin walls under clamp load crack; keep walls above 1.5 mm and support them in soft jaws. PC is more forgiving on fixturing but creeps under sustained clamp pressure, so hold critical bores with a stable fixture, not with vise torque. Both plastics absorb some moisture, but PC absorbs more and moves more with humidity, which matters for optical sensors that depend on a fixed air gap. The polycarbonate versus acrylic guide on this site compares the two on a feature-by-feature basis.
Chemicals, cosmetics, and cost
Acrylic is attacked by ketones and many solvents, including some inks and adhesives, and stress-cracks if wiped with alcohol-based cleaners. PC resists dilute acids and oils but crazes under gasoline, solvents, and aromatic hydrocarbons; if the part lives in a shop with oil mist, PC is the safer default. On appearance, acrylic polishes to a mirror and takes flame polishing beautifully, while PC ends up satin or polished but never quite as optically flat without a post-polish step. On price, acrylic sheet is usually USD 5-15 per kilogram, PC runs USD 12-25 per kilogram, and machined parts carry that difference straight into the quote. For a one-off prototype, the cost gap is trivial; for a 5,000-piece enclosure, it is real money. The acrylic CNC machining guide lists the setups that keep clear parts clear.
The decision in one paragraph
Choose acrylic when the part is a window, a lens, a display bezel, or anything where optical clarity and polish matter more than surviving a drop, and when the operating temperature stays below 80 C and the chemicals are mild. Choose polycarbonate when the part is a guard, a shield, an enclosure that ships, a part near a heat source, or anything a user might knock, step on, or ship across the world. If the part needs both, ask about coated PC: hard-coated Lexan (MR10, MARGARD) approaches acrylic scratch resistance while keeping PC impact, at about 30-50 percent sheet premium. For quick trade-offs on other clear plastics, the clear plastic parts guide covers the same ground with a different angle, and a coupon cut from each sheet tells you more than a datasheet ever will.
