All three are copper alloys, and all three machine on the same CNC lathe. They are not interchangeable. Brass cuts like butter and threads cleanly. Bronze carries load and wears well. Copper conducts heat and electricity and fights the tooling that tries to cut it. Picking the wrong one means either overpaying for bronze when brass would do, or underpaying for brass where bronze is the only material that survives. This article lines the three up on machinability, mechanicals, and cost so the choice is a calculation, not a guess.
What each one actually is
Copper is the base metal, over 99 percent pure. Brass is copper plus zinc, typically 30-40 percent Zn, which is what makes it strong and free-cutting. Bronze is copper plus tin (or aluminum, or silicon, or lead), which is what makes it tough, wear-resistant, and expensive. The family tree matters because machinability, corrosion behavior, and price all trace back to the alloying elements. Free-machining brass (C36000) adds lead for chip breaking; leaded bronze (C93200, the bearing bronze) does the same for bearing surfaces. Pure copper (C11000) has no chip-breaking alloy at all, which is why it is the hardest of the three to machine. Our brass versus bronze comparison explains the alloy families in more depth.
Machinability on the machine
C360 free-cutting brass is the benchmark. It machines at 600-1,200 SFM, produces short chips, leaves a clean surface, and is friendly to both carbide and HSS tooling. A 20 mm brass hex on a Swiss-type lathe will run 3-5 seconds per part. Bronze sits a step slower. Leaded bearing bronze cuts at 250-500 SFM and needs slightly heavier feeds to work-harden the chip instead of rubbing. Aluminum bronze (C95400) is tougher still, work-hardens under a dull tool, and demands sharp edges and rigid setups. Pure copper is the struggle: it smears, work-hardens, and gummy-built-up edge follows the tool. Run copper at 200-400 SFM with sharp geometry, ample feed, and a sharp eye on built-up edge, or the surface finish will tell you. Our guide to CNC machining copper covers the speeds and grades that work.
Mechanicals and where each earns its place
Brass (C360) yields around 120-170 MPa and looks great, but it is not a bearing material. It shows up in fittings, valve bodies, connector contacts, decorative hardware, and anything threaded. Bronze (C932, phosphor bronze C510) yields 200-300 MPa and has the wear and seizure resistance that makes it the default for bushings, thrust washers, gears, and worm wheels. Pure copper yields only 70 MPa but conducts at 400-590 W/m-K, which is why it shows up in bus bars, electrode holders, heat sinks, and vacuum chambers. Do not use a brass bushing where a bronze bushing is called for; the brass will gall in six months. Do not use a bronze connector body where conductivity matters; you are paying a premium for conductivity you are not using. The brass CNC machining guide lists the grades buyers usually stock.
Corrosion, plating, and cost
Brass shrugs off fresh water but tarnishes and dezincifies in acidic or salt environments; nickel or chrome plating fixes the look and slows the corrosion. Bronze handles salt and marine exposure better than brass, which is why marine hardware leans bronze. Copper handles corrosion beautifully, but it oxides green and needs a clear coat or plating when appearance matters. On price, brass is cheapest, bronze runs 1.5-3x brass depending on tin content, and pure copper usually sits between them but climbs with OFC or ETC grades for electrical use. Lead content is a hidden gate: C360 contains about 3 percent lead, which blocks RoHS-sensitive consumer and medical designs; lead-free brass (C37700 or similar) cuts a little harder and costs a bit more. Phosphor bronze machining notes cover the bearing-grade choice.
How to choose in one pass
Start with the function. If the part threads, fits, or decorates, brass is the default. If it slides, bears, or gears, bronze. If it conducts current or heat, copper. Then check the environment: salt water pushes you to bronze or plated copper; RoHS or food-contact rules you out of leaded brass. Then check the tolerance. All three hold ±0.01-0.02 mm on a rigid setup, but copper is the hardest to hold finish on, so expect a polishing or grinding pass if the surface matters. One last check: ask the shop which grade they stock in bar. Stocked bar means quote in days. A special-order alloy means a week of lead time and a minimum. The brass versus copper guide walks through the same decision on a narrower pair, and the phosphor bronze buyer guide goes deeper on the bearing choice. If you are still unsure after sketching the part, ask the shop for a one-square-inch coupon cut from each candidate alloy and inspect the chip shape, the surface, and the feel of the tool pressure. The coupon takes ten minutes and tells you more than a data sheet.
