The question is almost never which process is better. It is which process is cheaper at your volume, and the answer flips once, somewhere between 500 and 5,000 parts. Below that line, CNC machining wins. Above it, a molded part costs pennies on the dollar. The mistake buyers make is choosing the process first and working backwards, instead of pricing the part at their actual annual quantity and seeing where the line falls. This article breaks the cost into its pieces and puts real numbers on the crossover.
The fixed cost problem
Injection molding starts with a mold. A simple two-plate mold for a small plastic bracket runs USD 5,000-20,000; a multi-cavity mold with side actions, lifters, or polished surfaces runs USD 30,000-80,000. That money is spent before the first good part drops out. Machining has no equivalent fixed hardware cost. It has setup cost instead: a few hours of programming, fixturing, and proving out, typically USD 150-500 for a simple part. Fixed cost is the whole story on day one. Mold amortization divides the mold cost across every part; the higher the volume, the thinner that slice gets. Setup cost amortizes the same way, but the base is small, so it stops mattering after a handful of parts.
The per-piece cost problem
Once the machine is running, the cost inside each part splits differently. Machining pays for machine time per part. A CNC mill running aluminum or plastic at USD 40-75 per hour churns out parts at a rate that depends on cycle time: a 15-minute cycle means USD 10-19 of machine time per part, before tool wear and inspection. Material is a small share of that. Molding pays mostly for cycle time in the press, which is seconds, plus a small per-shot resin cost. A 60-second cycle in a 150-ton press at USD 25-40 per hour costs about USD 0.40-0.70 per shot in machine time, and resin for a 50-gram part adds another USD 0.05-0.15. The per-piece gap is the reason the crossover exists: molding is cheap inside each part once the mold is paid for. The setup cost versus piece cost guide shows how these two lines are built on a real quote.
Where the crossover actually lands
Run the math. Take a bracket that machines for USD 18 per piece including setup amortized at 100 units, and molds for USD 1.80 per piece plus an USD 12,000 mold. At 100 parts, machining is USD 1,800 plus setup, molding is USD 12,000 plus 180. Machining wins by a factor of six. At 1,000 parts, machining is USD 18,000, molding is USD 13,800. Molding has just edged ahead. At 10,000 parts, machining is USD 180,000, molding is USD 30,000. The crossover for a part like this sits around 800-1,200 units. Larger parts, tighter tolerances, or expensive materials move the crossover higher because the machined per-piece cost climbs. Small, simple parts in cheap resin cross over closer to 300-500 units. Our CNC versus injection molding comparison walks through the crossover math on several example geometries.
Hidden costs on both sides
Molding hides cost in tooling revisions and lead time. A mold that needs a steel-add or a weld after first articles adds USD 1,000-5,000 and pushes delivery out two to four weeks. Tooling wear on production molds means maintenance every 50,000-200,000 shots, and a badly designed gate or vent leaves cosmetic defects that require secondary work. Machining hides cost in revisions and inspection. Every design change restarts programming, and tight tolerances on CMM-checked features add hours of inspection per batch. Both processes eat money when the drawing is wrong on arrival. NRE fees and tooling costs are the line items to scrutinize most, because they are where silent markup hides.
The decision rule
Three questions settle it. What is the annual volume? Below 500 units, machining is almost always cheaper and faster. Between 500 and 10,000, ask for both quotes and plot the total cost on one axis. Above 10,000, molding wins on per-piece cost unless the geometry is unusually simple to machine and the mold unusually hard to build. How long is the product life? A product that ships for six months does not amortize a 12-week mold build. A product that ships for five years pays the mold back many times. What material and tolerance do you need? Glass-filled engineering resins at tight tolerances are molding-friendly; metals, hard-to-machine plastics like PEEK, and features that demand ±0.01 mm are machining-friendly. For a deeper look at how to compare the two quotes line by line, the low-volume versus mass production guide covers the decision matrix buyers use. One last point on lead time: a mold adds six to twelve weeks of tooling lead time before first shots, while a machined part ships in five to ten days. If the product is still in iteration, that schedule difference is often worth more than the per-piece gap, because you can test three design revisions for the price of one mold try-out.
